Updated: 08/05/2022 to reflect the new Outdoor Griddle Base From Steelmade USA.
Have you found yourself wondering what the differences between Blackstone Griddles and Steelmade USA Griddles are?
Well, I know, and want to share with you some key differences, because these two companies are not the same in many ways.
I’ve found myself comparing the Blackstone griddle, a great standalone tool that gets grilling done right, and the Steelmade USA Flat Tops, which are essentially an add-on to your pre-existing grills.
I decided to look into the two products and see which one looks better from a neutral perspective.
Now, remember, I’m not trying to convince you that one is better than the other or that you must avoid one at all costs. It’s your choice, but I’m happy to help where I can!
I’m just trying to give you some of my insight to ensure you make an informed decision if you’re looking to buy one of the products and are unsure which one works best for you.
Steelmade vs Blackstone: Battle Of The Brands
Let’s start with the Blackstone griddles, then, shall we? Blackstone griddles are standalone grills designed for use in your yard. They are remarkable pieces of kit that get the grilling done right.
Also, as a side note, I have one. I’ll try not to allow my bias to come into play, but it works wonders for me. You can’t go wrong with a Blackstone griddle if you’re looking to start hosting some outdoor parties or BBQs.
On the other hand, Steelmade makes both stand alone outdoor griddles (like Blackstone), but also a huge line of stove top and grill top griddle attachments to convert your current grills or stoves into griddles!
A quick look at Steelmade Flat Top Grill reviews shows happy customer after happy customer.
They can be used both inside and outside, which is a little more versatile than the Blackstone griddle. You can also experiment with different techniques on a Steelmade USA Flat Top.
The Pros And Cons of Blackstone GriddlePros
Blackstone griddles have been manufactured to do their job right out of the box. They’re one of the leading companies in the market for a reason and know exactly how grilling should be done.
They come in a variety of makes and models, each one offering something slightly different. They’re also easy for beginners to pick up and are a great way to learn about grilling, even if you’ve never done it before.
The biggest issue with the Blackstone griddle, when compared to the Steelmade USA Flat Tops, is the fact that it is its own unit.
If you’ve already got a grill, you’ll end up taking up twice as much space when you want to get yourself a Blackstone.
Unlike Steelmade, Blackstone doesn’t offer a griddle top to be placed on existing appliances you may own.
Of course, you could opt to get rid of your old grill, but it’s useful to have both grilling various foods when needed. Hopefully, you’ve got the yard space for it!
Steelmade USA Pros and Cons
It’s lightweight and easy to attach, making it a solid contender for the Blackstone griddle. It’s also a space-saver.
Since it doesn’t need its own space and can be clipped onto a grill you already own, you’ll be happy to save the yard space for more important things (like extra chairs for friends and family when you show off your impressive new grilling tech).
It’s also a little more versatile; you don’t just have to be forced to grill with the Steelmade. You’re perfectly capable of more traditional cooking methods with the Steelmade USA too.
The only thing that stands out as a con against the Blackstone is that the Steelmade Flat Tops aren’t quite as easy to find as a Blackstone.
You can’t swing by Walmart or Home Depot to pick up a Steelmade Griddle, you will need to order from their website. Not that its hard, just might be frustrating for those of us who are impatient.
It’s not enough for me, but it might be for you!
Where Are They Made?
Sometimes, people can decide based on the manufacturing countries, so I thought it best to include that for you quickly.
It’s entirely up to you how you decide to make up your mind, but I know that some people prefer something that’s a little more home-grown. If that’s the case for you, then Steelmade USA is the go-to. It’s in the name, after all.
Steelmade USA is a company set up and operating in the US. Blackstone, on the other hand, manufactures in China, which is where most things come from anyway!
I can appreciate, though, that some people might be inclined to lean towards US-made products, especially considering the differences in the communication you could get with customer service within your own country and customer service in another (with a completely different time zone, mind you).
What About Warranties?
Perhaps one of the most important things when weighing up your options is considering the warranties that come with each of the products. Of course, a warranty is setting you up for success no matter what you’re using.
If ever your product will break (and it can happen at the most inopportune times), then a warranty will have you covered.
Blackstone has a 1-year warranty included in all of their products to ensure that you get the best experience out of that first year.
If your unit breaks any time within that frame, you’re going to have an easy time getting a new one. However, the exciting news is that the Steelmade Griddle actually comes with a lifetime warranty.
Now, you can’t go wrong with that. No matter when it breaks (or if, for the optimists), you’ll always be covered with a Steelmade Flat Top.
Learn more here at Steelmade USA:
- The base is constructed from 14 gauge American Steel - over 2x thicker than competing cooktops from other manufacturers.
- Made in Kansas using American Steel
- Steel components and burner feature a Lifetime Warranty
- Hand-oiled finish is easy to maintain and never cracks or peels
For a full rundown of the NEW Steelmade Outdoor Griddle, check out the release info here.
As you can see, it’s pretty easy to make a distinguishable difference when it comes to Steelmade vs Blackstone flat top. Between build quality, warranties and country of manufacturing, Steelmade USA Griddles are hands down the winner.
They both do a fantastic job for what they’re designed to do, and it really comes down to personal preference as to which one you’d rather stick with.
As much as I like hearing myself talk (or type, in this case), I shouldn’t be the determining factor in your decision-making.
I hope you take what I’ve said into account to help you make the best decision you can! Good luck!