AmeriGas vs. Blue Rhino: A Grillers’ Grudge Match

Affiliate Disclaimer: Some of the links on this website may be affiliate links, meaning that I may receive a small commission if you click on the link and purchase the item. This helps to support my website and keep my content free for everyone.

AmeriGas vs Blue Rhino, the two leaders in providing the much needed lifeblood of grilling, propane. But, which is best?

Now, you might be thinking, “Propane? Isn’t that just… gas?” Well, dear reader, while propane is indeed a type of gas, it’s the invisible hero that turns your raw ingredients into char-grilled masterpieces.

But not all propane is created equal, and the provider you choose can make a world of difference in your grilling experience.

Choosing the right propane provider is like choosing the right barbecue sauce. Sure, they all do the job, but the right one can elevate your grilling from good to great.

It’s not just about the propane itself, but also about the reliability of delivery, the quality of customer service, and yes, even the shape and design of the propane tank. 

In the world of propane, two names often rise to the top: Blue Rhino and AmeriGas. Both are titans in the industry, but which one is the right choice for your grilling needs?

In this article, we’ll grill these two companies (pun absolutely intended), comparing their histories, services, products, and more. 

So, grab your tongs and your favorite apron, and let’s dive into the sizzling world of propane providers.

Fast Answer: When it comes to the propane itself, there’s no significant difference between AmeriGas and Blue Rhino. Propane is propane, regardless of the provider. It’s a clean-burning, environmentally friendly fuel that’s ideal for grilling. The quality of the propane doesn’t vary between providers like AmeriGas and Blue Rhino.

black and blue gas stove
Photo by Honye Sanges on

AmeriGas vs Blue Rhino Propane: Which Is Best For Grilling?

Ah, the million-dollar question: AmeriGas or Blue Rhino, which is the best for grilling? Well, dear reader, the answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think.

Both AmeriGas and Blue Rhino offer high-quality propane and convenient exchange services that can fuel your grilling adventures.

If you’re looking for a wider range of services and outdoor living products, AmeriGas might be your top pick.

But if it’s wide availability and a focus on quality assurance that you’re after, then Blue Rhino could be your grilling champion.

In the end, the “best” choice depends on your specific needs, preferences, and the kind of grilling journey you’re embarking on.

So, whether you choose AmeriGas or Blue Rhino, rest assured that either way, you’re in for a sizzling grilling experience.

a man installing a blue rhino propane tank on his grill

About Blue Rhino

Let’s start with Blue Rhino, a company that, despite its name, has nothing to do with large, horned mammals and everything to do with propane.

Founded in 1994 in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, Blue Rhino started with a simple yet revolutionary idea: to make propane tank exchanges as easy and convenient as buying a soda from a vending machine.

And just like that, the “propane vending machine” was born.

Today, Blue Rhino is a household name, known for its distinctive blue-and-white propane tanks available at more than 45,000 retail locations in 50 states. But Blue Rhino isn’t just about propane tanks.

They’ve also branched out into the world of grilling accessories, offering everything from barbecue tools and grill covers to bug zappers and patio heaters.

If it’s related to outdoor living, chances are, Blue Rhino has got it.

But what really sets Blue Rhino apart is their commitment to safety and quality. Each Blue Rhino tank is inspected, cleaned, and leak-tested before being filled with propane.

So, when you pick up a Blue Rhino tank, you can grill with confidence, knowing that you’re using a product that’s as safe as it is reliable.

connecting amerigas propane to grill

About AmeriGas

Next up, we have AmeriGas, a company that’s been in the propane business for over 60 years.

Founded in 1959, AmeriGas has grown from a small regional propane supplier to a national powerhouse, serving over 2 million customers in all 50 states.

AmeriGas offers a wide range of services, from residential propane delivery to commercial and industrial services.

But for the grilling enthusiast, AmeriGas’s most relevant offering is their grill cylinder exchange service, available at thousands of locations nationwide.

Like Blue Rhino, AmeriGas also places a strong emphasis on safety, with each cylinder undergoing a thorough inspection and maintenance process before being refilled.

But AmeriGas isn’t just about propane. They also offer a range of outdoor living products, including grills, smokers, and even fire pits.

So whether you’re a casual griller or a hardcore BBQ enthusiast, AmeriGas has got you covered.

In the end, both Blue Rhino and AmeriGas have a lot to offer to the grilling community. But which one is the right choice for you?

Well, dear reader, that’s a question we’ll tackle in the next section. So stay tuned, because things are about to get even hotter!

Comparing Blue Rhino and AmeriGas

Now that we’ve introduced our propane protagonists, it’s time for the main event: the head-to-head comparison.

Let’s see how Blue Rhino and AmeriGas stack up in terms of availability, product offerings, pricing, and customer service.

Availability and Accessibility

When it comes to availability, both Blue Rhino and AmeriGas have a strong presence across the United States.

Blue Rhino boasts over 45,000 retail locations, while AmeriGas serves over 2 million customers nationwide.

So, whether you’re grilling in the Golden State or barbecuing in the Bay State, chances are you’ll find either a Blue Rhino or AmeriGas location near you.

But what about accessibility? Well, both companies offer convenient propane tank exchange services, allowing you to swap your empty tank for a full one in a matter of minutes.

It’s as easy as picking up a pack of hot dogs for your next cookout.

Product Offerings

In terms of product offerings, both Blue Rhino and AmeriGas go beyond just propane.

Blue Rhino offers a range of grilling accessories, from barbecue tools to patio heaters, while AmeriGas offers grills, smokers, and fire pits.

So, whether you’re looking to upgrade your grilling game or create the perfect outdoor living space, both companies have got you covered.


When it comes to pricing, things can get a bit tricky. Propane prices can vary based on factors like location, demand, and even the time of year.

However, both Blue Rhino and AmeriGas strive to offer competitive pricing for their propane and other services.

It’s always a good idea to check the current prices at your local retailers or on the companies’ websites.

Customer Service

Last but certainly not least, we have customer service. Both Blue Rhino and AmeriGas pride themselves on their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Whether you have a question about your propane tank or need help with a delivery, both companies strive to provide prompt, helpful service.

However, as with any company, experiences may vary, and it’s always a good idea to check out customer reviews and ratings for a more complete picture.

So, who comes out on top in this propane showdown? Well, that depends on your specific needs and preferences.

But whether you choose Blue Rhino or AmeriGas, one thing’s for sure: with the right propane provider, your next barbecue is sure to be a sizzling success.

Pros and Cons of Blue Rhino

Let’s start with Blue Rhino, the propane provider with a name as unique as its service.


  1. Wide Availability: With over 45,000 retail locations across the country, you’re never too far from a Blue Rhino propane exchange station.
  2. Quality Assurance: Each Blue Rhino tank is inspected, cleaned, and leak-tested, so you can grill with confidence.
  3. Grilling Accessories: From barbecue tools to patio heaters, Blue Rhino offers a range of products to enhance your grilling experience.


  1. Limited Services: Blue Rhino primarily focuses on propane tank exchanges and grilling accessories, so if you’re looking for a broader range of services, you might need to look elsewhere.
  2. Pricing: While Blue Rhino strives to offer competitive pricing, costs can vary depending on location and retailer.

Pros and Cons of AmeriGas

Next, let’s take a look at AmeriGas, the propane provider that’s been fueling grills for over six decades.


  1. Nationwide Coverage: AmeriGas serves over 2 million customers across all 50 states, making it a reliable choice no matter where you live.
  2. Wide Range of Services: From residential propane delivery to grill cylinder exchanges, AmeriGas offers a variety of services to meet your needs.
  3. Outdoor Living Products: In addition to propane, AmeriGas offers grills, smokers, and fire pits to help you create the perfect outdoor living space.


  1. Pricing: As with Blue Rhino, AmeriGas’s pricing can vary based on location, demand, and other factors.
  2. Customer Service: While AmeriGas prides itself on its customer service, experiences can vary, so it’s worth checking out customer reviews and ratings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a difference in the quality of propane from AmeriGas and Blue Rhino?

No, the propane itself is the same regardless of whether it comes from AmeriGas or Blue Rhino. Propane is a standard product, and its quality doesn’t vary between providers.

Can I use either AmeriGas or Blue Rhino propane for my griddle?

Yes, you can use propane from either AmeriGas or Blue Rhino for your griddle. Both companies provide propane that is suitable for a variety of outdoor cooking appliances, including griddles.

I’m into smoking meats. Is there a preferred propane provider for smokers?

Both AmeriGas and Blue Rhino propane can be used for smokers. The choice of provider would depend more on factors like availability, price, and customer service rather than the propane itself.

Can I Use Forklift Propane in my Grill?

Yes, you can use forklift propane in your grill, but there are a few things to keep in mind.Forklift propane tanks and grill propane tanks are not the same, even though they both contain propane. Forklift propane tanks are typically larger and have different fittings and valves compared to grill propane tanks.If you want to use forklift propane for your grill, you would need an adapter to connect the forklift propane tank to your grill. These adapters can be found at hardware stores or online.

Are there any safety differences between AmeriGas and Blue Rhino propane tanks?

Both AmeriGas and Blue Rhino prioritize safety. Their propane tanks undergo thorough inspections and maintenance processes before being refilled. Always follow the safety guidelines provided by the company and general propane safety practices.

Can I exchange an AmeriGas propane tank at a Blue Rhino location, or vice versa?

Typically, you can exchange any brand of propane tank at either AmeriGas or Blue Rhino locations as long as the tank meets current safety standards. However, it’s always a good idea to check with the specific location to confirm their policy.

Is one brand more environmentally friendly than the other?

Propane itself is an environmentally friendly fuel source, producing fewer greenhouse gases than many other fuels. Both AmeriGas and Blue Rhino provide propane, but any differences in environmental impact would come down to company practices rather than the propane itself.

I’m a beginner in grilling. Which propane provider is better for beginners?

Both AmeriGas and Blue Rhino are suitable for beginners. The choice depends on factors like the convenience of their services, availability in your area, and pricing. Both companies also offer resources and support that can be helpful for beginners.

Does AmeriGas or Blue Rhino offer better accessories for grilling?

Both companies offer a range of grilling accessories. Blue Rhino has a specific focus on grilling accessories, while AmeriGas offers a broader range of outdoor living products. The “better” choice would depend on what specific accessories you’re looking for.

Are there any cost differences between AmeriGas and Blue Rhino for grilling needs?

Costs can vary depending on location, current market conditions, and the specific services or products you’re purchasing. It’s best to check the current prices at your local retailers or on the companies’ websites.

Which company has better customer service, AmeriGas or Blue Rhino?

Customer service experiences can vary. Both companies strive to provide excellent customer service, but it’s always a good idea to check out customer reviews and ratings for a more complete picture.


Choosing between Blue Rhino and AmeriGas is like choosing between a juicy steak and a perfectly grilled burger—both are great choices, but the best one depends on your specific tastes and needs. 

Blue Rhino shines with its wide availability and quality assurance, making it a reliable choice for grillers who value convenience and peace of mind.

On the other hand, AmeriGas offers a wider range of services and outdoor living products, making it a versatile choice for those looking to do more than just grill.

In the end, the best propane provider for you is the one that meets your grilling needs, fits your budget, and gives you the confidence to grill your best.

So whether you choose Blue Rhino, AmeriGas, or another provider, remember: the secret to great grilling isn’t just in the propane—it’s also in the passion, skill, and joy you bring to the grill.